Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

--- detailed_listing_of_other_literature [2014/02/12 10:43] – firth
+++ detailed_listing_of_other_literature [2014/03/01 18:16] – firth
@@ Line 27: / Line 27: @@
 [[http://cdli.ucla.edu/search/search_results.php?SearchMode=Text&requestFrom=Search&PrimaryPublication=&order=PrimaryPublication&Author=&PublicationDate=&SecondaryPublication=&Collection=&AccessionNumber=&MuseumNumber=&Provenience=&ExcavationNumber=&Period=&DatesReferenced=&ObjectType=&ObjectRemarks=&Material=&TextSearch=&Language=&Genre=&SubGenre=&CompositeNumber=q000762&SealID=&ObjectID=&ATFSource=&CatalogueSource=&TranslationSource=| etcsl 5.3.3 = Q000762: The debate between Winter and Summer]]
-In CDLI, CBS 13857+ incorporates many fragments (as listed by Gerardi OPBK 8, 173). CDLI follows Vanstiphout (NABU 1987, 87) and joins CBS 8886 to Ni 4004, Ni 4068 & Ni 9909 (i.e. at this stage, it does not join Ni 4004 to CBS 13857). Similarly, CBS 8310 includes more fragments than those listed by etcsl. CDLI lists Ni 2750 as etcsl 5.1.1 (an edubba text) but gives Ni 2705 as Winter & Summer, so perhaps the etcsl list should have included Ni 2705 instead of Ni 2750. CDLI also lists Ni 4359 and N 3254+.
+In CDLI, CBS 13857+ incorporates many fragments (as listed by Gerardi OPBK 8, 173). At this stage, CDLI follows Vanstiphout (NABU 1987, 87) and joins CBS 8886 to Ni 4004, Ni 4068 & Ni 9909 (i.e. it does not join Ni 4004 to CBS 13857). Similarly, CBS 8310 includes more fragments than those listed by etcsl. CDLI lists Ni 2750 as etcsl 5.1.1 (an edubba text) but gives Ni 2705 as Winter & Summer, so perhaps the etcsl list should have included Ni 2705 instead of Ni 2750. CDLI also lists Ni 4359 and N 3254+. Vanstiphout (NABU 1987, 087 lists Ni 9799 (ISET 1, 185) under this heading.
 [[http://cdli.ucla.edu/search/search_results.php?SearchMode=Text&requestFrom=Search&PrimaryPublication=&order=PrimaryPublication&Author=&PublicationDate=&SecondaryPublication=&Collection=&AccessionNumber=&MuseumNumber=&Provenience=&ExcavationNumber=&Period=&DatesReferenced=&ObjectType=&ObjectRemarks=&Material=&TextSearch=&Language=&Genre=&SubGenre=&CompositeNumber=q000764&SealID=&ObjectID=&ATFSource=&CatalogueSource=&TranslationSource=| etcsl 5.3.5 = Q000764: The debate between Bird and Fish]]
@@ Line 55: / Line 55: @@
 [[http://cdli.ucla.edu/search/search_results.php?SearchMode=Text&requestFrom=Search&PrimaryPublication=&order=PrimaryPublication&Author=&PublicationDate=&SecondaryPublication=&Collection=&AccessionNumber=&MuseumNumber=&Provenience=&ExcavationNumber=&Period=&DatesReferenced=&ObjectType=&ObjectRemarks=&Material=&TextSearch=&Language=&Genre=&SubGenre=&CompositeNumber=q000778&SealID=&ObjectID=&ATFSource=&CatalogueSource=&TranslationSource=| etcsl 5.5.4 = Q000778: The song of the hoe]]
-In CDLI, CBS 13122, CBS 13382, CBS 13864 & CBS 13877 are listed as both Song of the Hoe (etcsl 5.5.4) and Debate between Hoe and Plough (etcsl 5.3.1). In CDLI, N 7260 is joined to N 1737+. The tablet listed as UCLM 9-2857 is given in CDLI as HMA 9-02857; that listed as ROM D-1034 is given in CDLI as ROM 910x209.501, with accession no. 1034. In the listing of the UET 6/3 fragments, etcsl 5.5.4 omits the asterisks denoting provisional numbers; the relevant published UET 6/3 nos. are 643-645 and 726. Etcsl lists 3N-T674 = IM 58609; however, in CDLI 3N-T674 = IM 58690 and it is a lexical tablet.
+In CDLI, CBS 13122, CBS 13382, CBS 13864 & CBS 13877 are listed as both Song of the Hoe (etcsl 5.5.4) and Debate between Hoe and Plough (etcsl 5.3.1). In CDLI, N 7260 is joined to N 1737+. The tablet listed as UCLM 9-2857 is given in CDLI as HMA 9-02857; that listed as ROM D-1034 is given in CDLI as ROM 910x209.501, with accession no. 1034. In the listing of the UET 6/3 fragments, etcsl 5.5.4 omits the asterisks denoting provisional numbers; the relevant published UET 6/3 nos. are 643-645 and 726. Etcsl lists 3N-T674 = IM 58609; however, in CDLI 3N-T674 = IM 58690 and it is a lexical tablet. CDLI adds K 6697 + K 8069 (obv.).
 [[http://cdli.ucla.edu/search/search_results.php?SearchMode=Text&requestFrom=Search&PrimaryPublication=&order=PrimaryPublication&Author=&PublicationDate=&SecondaryPublication=&Collection=&AccessionNumber=&MuseumNumber=&Provenience=&ExcavationNumber=&Period=&DatesReferenced=&ObjectType=&ObjectRemarks=&Material=&TextSearch=&Language=&Genre=&SubGenre=&CompositeNumber=q000779&SealID=&ObjectID=&ATFSource=&CatalogueSource=&TranslationSource=| etcsl 5.5.5 = Q000779: The song of the ploughing oxen: an ululumama to Ninurta]]
@@ Line 89: / Line 89: @@
 [[http://cdli.ucla.edu/search/search_results.php?SearchMode=Text&requestFrom=Search&PrimaryPublication=&order=PrimaryPublication&Author=&PublicationDate=&SecondaryPublication=&Collection=&AccessionNumber=&MuseumNumber=&Provenience=&ExcavationNumber=&Period=&DatesReferenced=&ObjectType=&ObjectRemarks=&Material=&TextSearch=&Language=&Genre=&SubGenre=&CompositeNumber=q000794&SealID=&ObjectID=&ATFSource=&CatalogueSource=&TranslationSource=| etcsl 5.9.2 = Q000794: The heron and the turtle]]
-In the etcsl list, N 2267 should be changed to N 2667.
+In the etcsl list, N 2267 should be changed to N 2667. To the etcsl list of print sources should now be added Peterson's PhD thesis. Peterson (pp.293-294) joins N 3072 to N 6741 and adds to the list Ist Ni 2526.